When fear enters the conversation: How brand respond to stakeholder anxiety

Fear, driven by cultural shifts or global crises, can significantly impact how audiences perceive a brand’s trustworthiness, relevance and value – brands that ignore these shifts risk losing ground to more responsive competitors.

Timeless brands build emotional connections based on human feelings like joy and belonging. What happens, though, when fear enters the conversation?

Sometimes fear is directed at your brand because of missteps like product safety lapses that need to be corrected. But sometimes, fear stems from consumers’ values changing, which brings more scrutiny around entire categories. In addition, there is a more existential fear taking hold right now that reminds me of the pandemic. It stems from economic volatility, public health crises, AI uncertainty, and a lot more. Even if that fear is not directed at your brand, it can hurt you. Being an effective brand steward means understanding how to respond even when you did not do anything to bring on the fear.

Fear That Targets Your Category

Some challenges begin with the category you’re in. These are slow-burn pressures that build over time, shaped by growing public awareness, shifting cultural norms, or emerging research. When a category becomes linked to health concerns, environmental issues, or social critiques, brands are pushed to act. But these moments also offer an opportunity: to lead transformation. The most successful brands reimagine the role their category plays in people’s lives.

The Beverage Industry: Quietly Leading a Cultural Shift

Health and wellness trends have reshaped the beverage landscape, challenging legacy categories like sugary sodas and alcoholic drinks to evolve. Many leading brands have taken proactive steps to anticipate what consumers want next. Diageo has invested in low- and no-alcohol offerings. Coca-Cola and PepsiCo have expanded their portfolios with zero-sugar, functional beverages, and enhanced hydration options.

These shifts have provided consumers with choices that reflect their evolving values and lifestyles. The transformation is happening both on the surface and behind the scenes. On shelves, you see it in product launches like Guinness 0.0 or Coke Zero Sugar, and in-store messaging that speaks to balance and enjoyment without compromise. Behind the scenes, these companies are investing in R&D, health-forward ingredients, and strategic acquisitions such as BodyArmor and Celsius that reflect where the category is heading.

The “treat yourself” narratives of the past are being replaced by messaging that speaks to personalization, performance, and wellbeing. Consider PepsiCo’s Gatorade FIT line, designed for wellness-conscious athletes, or Diageo’s efforts to make non-alcoholic options feel just as socially integrated and celebratory.

The takeaway: when your category is in transition, you have an opportunity to redefine it. Leading brands are doing both—launching new products that meet evolving needs, while holding onto what made them beloved in the first place: taste, refreshment, and moments of connection.

Fashion: Understanding Emotional Drivers

The fashion industry has become a high-profile case study in how sustainability-related fears can reshape an entire category. Once celebrated for its creativity and constant reinvention, fashion is under scrutiny for its outsized environmental impact. Consumers are increasingly associating the category with overflowing landfills, carbon-heavy production, and water pollution—especially from fast fashion, which churns out low-cost garments at breakneck speed. Shoppers are beginning to feel that their closets could be contributing to climate collapse, and that’s the root fear here: will the world stop being a healthy place to live?

This growing unease has forced brands to rethink what it means to be relevant. Sustainability must be woven into the fabric of the brand. Patagonia has become the benchmark, having embraced sustainability as a long-term business strategy rather than a short-term PR play. Its resale platform, Worn Wear, and its investments in circular design have helped build a new consumer mindset centered on durability and repair.

The brands that are winning trust aren’t necessarily those claiming perfection. They’re making measurable progress and inviting consumers into the process. Levi’s, for instance, launched a “Buy Better, Wear Longer” platform around educating customers on garment care, water conservation, and low-impact materials. The message is less about absolution and more about partnership: we’re trying to do better, and here’s how you can help.

The learning: when fear shadows an entire category, the answer isn’t to reassure consumers that everything is fine. It’s to take action that shows you’re listening, and to build a new path forward that aligns with their values. In sustainability-driven categories, brand relevance is increasingly earned through accountability, not aspiration.

When the World Gets Noisy

Sometimes, the fear isn’t about your category, but it still affects your audiences. This is ambient fear: economic collapse, pandemic paralysis, market unease. It’s what happens when consumer confidence dips or employees start wondering if layoffs are next. Brands need to understand the emotional drivers of this kind of fear and respond to them because even if their reputations are not at risk, their businesses certainly are.

Hyundai Assurance: Turning Economic Fear Into Brand Trust

During the 2008–2009 recession, consumer confidence hit historic lows. Millions of people were out of work, and those still employed feared they might be next. In that climate, the idea of taking on a new car loan felt irresponsible, if not impossible. It wasn’t that people were uninterested in buying cars. They were afraid to.

Most automakers responded with discounts, rebates, or extended financing. Hyundai took a different path. It acknowledged the emotional reality of the moment and leaned into it with a simple, bold offer: if you bought or leased a new Hyundai and lost your job within a year, you could return the car—penalty-free, with no impact on your credit.

Called Hyundai Assurance, the program addressed consumer anxiety head-on. It gave buyers a psychological safety net when they needed it most. And it reframed Hyundai from a value brand into one that understood real life.

The move was transformative. While competitors struggled, Hyundai enjoyed increases in sales and market share. Customers felt seen. And Hyundai proved that empathy, when backed by real risk-taking, could be a brand builder.

The learning: When external fear paralyzes your audience, addressing the emotion behind the hesitation is often more powerful than changing the product itself. Hyundai didn’t offer a better deal. It offered relief. By designing a program that matched the psychological needs of the moment, the company moved minds.

Raising Cane’s: Managing Fear Through Coordinated Action

When COVID-19 hit, fear swept through the restaurant industry. Customers worried about health and safety. Employees feared exposure and job loss. Sales at quick-service chains like Raising Cane’s dropped by as much as 30%. Across the industry, layoffs followed. But Raising Cane’s took a different path. The company understood that layoffs might offer short-term relief but would threaten its ability to rebound once customers returned. More than that, the company saw that fear—of going out, of getting sick—was now the main barrier to doing business.

Rather than wait out the storm, Raising Cane’s acted fast. It rapidly shifted its business model, bolstering its drive-thru operations with additional staffing, simplified menus, and operational enhancements to keep lines moving and reduce friction. Crew members with tablets were dispatched to take orders directly from cars, cutting wait times and easing customer concerns. Behind the scenes, health protocols were tightened and strictly enforced. Masking, sanitization, and social distancing became standard.

Meanwhile, the company’s marketing shifted in lockstep with its operations. The focus moved from product promotions to transparency, safety, and reassurance. Customers saw a brand taking responsibility.

The result was a rare thing in 2020: a brand that remained visible, stable, and trusted. Sales rebounded quickly. Employee morale stayed high. And Raising Cane’s emerged not just intact, but stronger, anchored by a culture that proved it could adapt and still put people first.

The learning: Fear demands a coordinated response in addition to a rapid one. Raising Cane’s succeeded because it treated fear as a cross-functional challenge. By aligning operations, staffing, and marketing around a clear set of priorities such as safety, service, and trust, the brand showed how resilience can be designed.

AI Joins the Table but Doesn’t Replace the Host

As fear takes different shapes, brands now have a new tool to help them track, interpret, and sometimes preempt it: AI. AI-powered listening tools can detect rising anxiety before it becomes a full-blown backlash. AI-driven chatbots can field panicked questions at scale. Predictive models can flag which customer segments are most at risk of churning as a result of economic pressure.

This is useful, but it’s not the endgame. AI can tell you what’s being said. It can’t tell you why it matters. It can map sentiment. But it can’t feel emotion. When fear escalates, audiences want clarity and accountability. They want to feel like someone real is on the other side of the conversation. That’s why the future isn’t AI or human. It’s AI plus human judgment. The tech gives you the signal. The brand gives it meaning.

What Fear Teaches Us About Brand Leadership

Fear, like brand meaning, evolves. It adapts. Sometimes it targets you. Sometimes it surrounds you. But in both cases, how you respond defines you. Successful brands read the room. They move faster. They speak more clearly. And most of all, they act in ways that respond to their audiences. Resilience doesn’t mean pretending fear doesn’t exist. It means showing up differently because it does.

Featured in WARC